I don’t want to come across as dismissive, mainly because I’ve had middle school boys and I KNOW how it feels to want to throttle them! BUT. . . sometimes I just want to say, “If I had a quarter for every parent who’s said something like, ‘My middle school boy just isn’t performing up to his ability,‘ I’d be a WEALTHY woman! Really, I hear that complaint at least once a week, so much that I’ve come to feel that non-performance is almost the norm for that age guy. But, like I said, I’ve had boys that age and that non-performance mode and I KNOW how frustrating it can be. So I’d like to shed what light I can on the issue.
First of all, one difference between boys and girls noted by educational experts has to do with their motivations to learn. It seems that girls (mostly) are motivated by wanting to please others: their parents, their teachers, even their peers. Boys (mostly), on the other hand, are motivated to learn
- IF it interests them or IF they find the presentation of the material engaging or
- IF they see a reason to know the information.
And if we’re honest, how much of middle school meets either of those criteria? When we look at the teachers our boys love, they’re often those crazy, wild fun ones who’re 85% entertainer, 10% cop and 5% teacher. Once some boys hit high school, we can convince them that learning/performing has a purpose if none other than to gain their independence to go to college or live on their own. A few catch a glimmer of their own future, one they’ll have to build with their own work. But for most, that remains a distant illusion.
In an informal survey of well-educated, successful men in my community, I ask, “How old were you when you kicked it into gear academically?” (I double-dog dare you to ask a few men that question!) Exactly one said middle school (and I knew him in middle school and it was a little scary how intense he was); a few said junior year of high school (about the time they realized their grades really WERE going to determine where/if they went to college); most men told me they kicked it into gear about junior year of college AND more than one said, “What do you mean? I don’t think I HAVE kicked it yet!” I think these replies are why, on the whole, dads are not as concerned about their middle school boys as moms are!
So, how about some tips for what to do until IT happens:
- Don’t think of him or speak to him as if he were dumb; acknowledge that he hasn’t kicked it into gear. . . YET;
- Look for tiny sparks of engagement, curiosity, interest and fan the fires. . . even if the interest is fleeting;
- Look for areas not necessarily related to school where your boy chooses to learn, seeks information, or DOES exert effort and remind him, and yourself, that he’s the kind of guy who seeks to know stuff and CAN work hard when he chooses;
- If he is absolutely failing in middle school, you may need to tie minimal performance to things he wants to do (video games, sports, sleep overs). This goes along with teaching him the difference between “gottas” and “wannas.” In life there just ARE some things we’ve gotta do, for mom, for dad, for everyone, even for him! Do your gottas first so you can savor your wannas.
- When he gets it right, even if it’s just a tiny bit, acknowledge his improving grade, his new study habit, his coming home with the assignment written down.
Remember that in so many ways, he’s like a puppy who’s never met up with a leash. He really doesn’t want to quit playing in order to work. But with a bit of patience, consistency and understanding from you, I’ll bet you a quarter, he’ll do it!
I’ve got my quarter ready. . . .